“If history were taught in the form of stories, it would never be forgotten.” Rudyard Kipling

November 4, 2017 Island Teacher 107 comments

Trying to fit History teaching pedagogy into small quotes is often problematic. I recently was confronted with this situation while reading a newspaper article. The piece, published in the Guardian Newspaper was written by British journalist Janet Street-Porter. For those not familiar with Ms. Porter, it would not be contentious to say that she often questions the norms of institutions, particularly the BBC. She is no stranger to ‘calling out’ what she sees as needing debate or reflection. I often find myself at odds with her, but I can say that over the years I am grateful for her contribution, because it makes me stop and think. On pausing, I can often see my own cultural bias obscuring an alternative viewpoint. The article goes on to talk about our approaches to educating about the past through television and drama productions. This poses the question; how do we tell about the past?

In many British Schools, the story of Guy Fawkes and the Catholic plotters who planned to blow up the Houses of Parliament in 1605 is still a popular theme during the Fall term. This is a key moment in British history and the subsequent capture and brutal public execution are ever popular thanks to ‘Firework night’ events around the United Kingdom. It has recently been turned into an opportune drama series by the BBC. The interpretation and dramatisation of this 1605 event still manages to stir contentions. Critics according to Porter, have complained that Gunpowder glamorises terrorists and sanitises religious bigotry, with some viewers finding the scenes of torture (a noblewoman stripped and crushed to death, for example) highly upsetting.

In Miss Porter’s opinion, the show is,

“the latest example of a fashionable dramatic genre; history-light – where colourful periods in the past are presented in a highly selective way, with glittering actors and expensive special effects and posh people sounding thoroughly modern.”

For those of us at all stages of education, the challenge is how you present the past in an age-appropriate way that does its best not to dilute what we really know and also accommodate new emerging revaluations based on new evidence. In an online article, Susan I. Kent presents just such a challenge.

“Recently published test results indicating a DNA match between Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings’ youngest son offers the most compelling evidence to date that Jefferson may indeed have fathered at least one child by this slave given to him by his wife’s father. It had been long established—but little publicised until now—that Sally Hemings, whose slave mother was owned by Jefferson’s father-in-law, was Martha Jefferson’s illegitimate half-sister. These findings expose today’s students to complex issues about human character and the nation’s past from which some might have preferred to protect them.

 

thomas-jefferson-sally-hemings

Sarah “Sally” Hemings was an enslaved woman of mixed race owned by President Thomas Jefferson. Most historians believe Jefferson was the father of her six children, born after the death of his wife

 

This sort of new conclusive information makes it even more challenging to present issues like the founding fathers’ of the United States ownership of slaves.

Hemmings rightly poses the question. Should this recent evidence be discussed, and, if so, how might teachers best present it? Not only are some issues difficult for young children to understand, many are inappropriate for classroom discussion, especially in the Primary phase.

While educators are presented with such evidence, we are asked to champion the values that make our nations great. In England, the Department of Education has been pushing British Values so that government can develop more community cohesion. However, it is very difficult to choose not to remember the injustices that the British Empire also exported in its wholesale distribution of British Values. Of course, I write these words in the time that I live. Many no longer regard the British Empire through the imperial spectacles of the past that frame it into the nations ‘glorious history’

So how do we reconcile the need for authenticity in our presentation of history at a time when a growing number of schools aim to instill in children moral values such as respect and honesty through a resurgence of character education programs using historical figures from the past?

An even greater challenge confronting teachers is how to help students analyse and evaluate the conflicting perspectives and values that have emerged as a result of this evidence. How can the great accomplishments of leaders like Jefferson be reconciled with the implied serious character flaws that now appear undeniable? How can moral issues, such as slavery and freedom, equality, sexual conduct, and the right to privacy be understood in the context of their times and be weighed to determine which are most essential to the survival of a democracy?

One such dilemma recently surfaced in the former Slave Trade importation port of Bristol England. Here a local school, Colston’s Girls’ School faced that issue. The school bore the name of a prominent Slave Trader and ‘philanthropist’. He was a deputy governor of the Royal African Company which between 1672 and 1698  who transported around 100,000 enslaved Africans to plantations in the West Indies and America. In 1710, Colston set up a school for “100 poor boys”, then handed over the management of the school and his endowment to the Society of Merchant Venturers of Bristol

Edward Colston

Edward Colston Deputy Governor of the Royal African Company which between 1672 and 1698

 

I

The Headteacher Mr. Whitehead, in a letter to parents,  said: “It has been suggested that Colston’s Girls’ School should change its name in order to remove the association with Edward Colston.

“We have considered this suggestion and we have listened carefully to views on both sides. After much discussion, it has been agreed that it would not be appropriate to rename the school.”

He went on to explain: “There is no doubt that Colston’s Girls’ School exists today as an outstanding school for girls, nationally known for its academic excellence and well respected for its inclusivity and diversity – because of the financial endowment was given by Edward Colston,  but we see no benefit in denying the school’s financial origin and obscuring history itself.

“To the contrary, by enabling our students to engage thoughtfully with our past, we continue to encourage them to ask questions about present-day moral values and to stand up for what they believe is right.”

Are we in danger of ironing out all the complicated bits that don’t suit modern storytelling for a generation with a short attention span? Perhaps we need to work out how we can present the past without obscuring history itself even when we do not like our past.

107 Comments on ““If history were taught in the form of stories, it would never be forgotten.” Rudyard Kipling

  1. The other day, while I was at work, my sister stole my apple
    ipad and tested to see if it can survive a twenty five foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad
    is now broken and she has 83 views. I know this is totally off topic but
    I had to share it with someone!

  2. The main significance about this type is giving moisture to the skin and relaxation in the body.
    Sometimes it is almost cuddling, hanging out together, hugs
    and kisses. It is also necessary to get in the habit of working out regularly to keep up muscle
    strength preventing obesity.

  3. One should also keep in mind the target customer and the views
    towards a selected style, prior to buying the furniture of the store.
    Our lives are full of stress and countless responsibilities
    that can be overwhelmingly hectic at times.
    This is for the intention of easy gliding in the hand in the massage therapist on the
    parts which needs to be worked with consistently.

  4. It does not take a whole day to attend a massage session and you’ll
    schedule your appointments yourself, making it
    possible to fit it even in to the busiest day.
    The chair is made from such leather that’s very comfortable and warm therefore, you may feel comfortable with it.

    A well designed Rehabilitation program while
    using correct growth of proper stretching exercises will mean these basic functions might
    be preserved and improved upon.

  5. The therapist should have advanced training and experience in treating soft tissue injuries.

    Now you begin to massage your ears; start on top of
    your ears, then massage hard all way on the ear. The opening and expanding of arteries help
    in keeping the follicles widened.

  6. One should also keep in mind the mark customer and his views towards a
    particular style, before selecting the item of furniture with the store.

    You can download MP3 files onto the USB stick and plug it in to the port located on the chair.
    The opening and expanding of veins help in keeping the
    follicles widened.

  7. You may would like to place a tiny towel beneath your feet through the massage to prevent spilling the oil on your clothes or bedding.
    The chair is constucted from such leather which is very comfortable and warm and so, you will feel relaxed with it.
    This is for the intention of easy gliding of the hand from the massage therapist for the parts which needs to be caused consistently.

  8. The main need for this sort is giving moisture to
    the skin and relaxation with the body. The chair is made with such leather that is certainly very comfortable and warm therefore, you are going to feel comfortable with it.

    Individuals trying to become a certified massage
    therapist should develop a thorough educational training program.

  9. The main significance about this type is giving moisture towards the skin and relaxation from
    the body. The chair is produced with such leather that is
    very comfortable and warm therefore, you may feel safe with it.

    It is also necessary to get to the habit of working out to
    keep up muscle strength which will help prevent obesity.

  10. The main need for such a type is giving moisture to the skin and relaxation in the body.

    Sometimes it is pretty much cuddling, chilling together, hugs and kisses.
    A well designed Rehabilitation program with the correct progression of proper stretching exercises will mean these basic functions might be preserved and
    improved upon.

  11. The main significance of this kind is giving moisture
    towards the skin and relaxation from the body.
    Our lives are filled up with stress and countless responsibilities that
    could be overwhelmingly hectic at times. It is something which we recommend
    that couples do before they have problems.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.